About CLOs

About CLOs

by Shiloh Bates

What is a CLO?

CLOs provide investors with exposure to diversified portfolios of actively managed senior secured loans, with built in long-term financing.  Most of the CLO’s loans are created in Leveraged Buyouts (LBOs), where the secured loan makes up less than half of the enterprise value of the business.  The leveraged loan is senior and secured, has a floating rate, and is rated below investment grade by rating agencies.  The CLO’s financing is long-term and done on favorable terms.

Annual CLO issuance has increased since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC). What’s driving this growth? The two primary drivers, in my opinion, are investors seeking exposure to actively managed portfolios of first lien loans combined with the performance of CLO securities over extended periods of time.  As private equity AUM has grown, so, too, has CLO AUM.

Annual CLO Issuance ($bn)

Source: Nomura Securities CLO Research as of 12/31/2023

How do CLOs work?

The typical broadly syndicated CLO structure is about 500 million of assets. These are first lien loans, floating rate. They’re generally secured by all the assets of the company. That could include property, equipment, inventory, accounts receivable, intangible assets, etc. It’s all in there, pledged to the lenders. Again, these loans are usually created in leveraged buyouts.

The CLO is partially financed with investment-grade debt, rated AAA to BBB, sold primarily to insurance companies and banks. At Flat Rock Global, our focus is CLO BB Notes and CLO Equity, which are the junior securities issued by the CLO.

Broadly Syndicated CLO Structure

A CLO’s structure resembles a simplified bank. It allows investors to get exposure to first lien senior secured loans, but on a leveraged basis. A CLO uses securitization technology to divide the cash flows received from the pool of leveraged loans according to agreed-upon rules.

What's the difference between a CLO and CDO?

CLOs issued today have little in common with the Collateralized Debt Obligations (CDOs) issued before the financial crisis. May of those CDOs – featured in the book, The Big Short, by Michael Lewis, were backed by subprime mortgage loans of dubious quality. Securitization is a powerful tool, and the results can be favorable when quality assets are securitized, and the leverage is applied on appropriate terms and levels. The association of today’s CLOs with the failed CDOs of the past is one of the reasons that investors in CLOs can earn an excess return above comparable risk assets.

CLOs versus CDOs

Table showing a side by side comparison of the attributes of collateralized loan obligations and collateralized debt obligations

Why CLO equity?

Collateralized Loan Obligations (CLO) equity offers the potential for mid-teen returns with low correlation to other asset classes like equities or high yield bonds. CLO equity allows investors to gain exposure to a highly diversified pool of leveraged loans using attractive built-in leverage that’s locked in for the life of the CLO. In contrast to other alternative investments, there is no “J Curve” in CLO equity. That’s because the CLOs pay quarterly distributions, and the initial distributions are usually higher than later ones. The higher initial cash flows mitigate the investment risk and make it harder – though not impossible – to have a negative lifetime Internal Rate of Return (IRR).

A potential downside to CLO equity is volatility, which can be equity-like in some market environments. Surprisingly to many, CLOs issued before the financial crisis did very well on a buy-and-hold basis. Returns were aided by what we refer to as the “self-healing mechanism” specific to CLOs.

CLOs have historically been an asset only available to large institutional investors. Given what we believe is the attractive risk/return characterization of CLOs and CLO equity, in particular, we believe retail investors will increasingly want access to the asset class.

Why middle market CLO BB rated notes?

CLO BB Notes provide exposure to middle market loans in a format where loan losses are generally absorbed by the CLO’s equity investor.  CLO BB Notes have annual default rates of 0.22% since 1994, and offer yields above 12% today.